Ben Nye Cake Eye Liner


Select a Color
Black EL1
Black EL11 (0.18oz)
Brown EL5
Charcoal EL2
Dark Brown EL4
Dark Brown EL41 (0.18oz)
Eggplant EL6
Electric Blue EL7
Taupe EL55
White EL0
- +
Ben Nye's Cake Eye Liner allows you to achieve a clean edge and precise, delicate lining every time! More forgiving and softer than liquid eyeliner, this product is great for those who want to practice application with a steady hand!

Simply dip a wet brush of your choice into the cake liner and stir into a creamy, rich consistency for bold, definite color! May also be used with LiquiSet as an activating agent instead of water for longer lasting wear.

*Packaging may vary Pan size: 25mm. (2gm.)

Size: 0.07oz (EL11, EL41 0.18oz)  

Ben Nye Cake Eye Liner is also available in Refill Sizes! Pans for this fit into the Ben Nye Empty 14-Well Refillable Palette.

    Talc, Propylene Glycol, CL No. 7704 (Kaolin), PEG-8, PVP, Choleth-24, Ceteth-24, Emulsifying wax, Phenoxyethanol

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 29 reviews
    Joyce Bernstein
    Ben bye cake eyeliner

    Hard to find cake eyeliner anymore. Laura Mercier does not make it anymore. Great find!! Thanks

    Bonnie Kirschenbaum
    Ben Nye cake eye liner review

    I like the consistency and the fact that it goes on more like a gel than a water based product. The only issue is that I need to use eye drops once during the day and when I do the liner in the corners wash away so I need to re-apply.
    Other than that it stays on all day.

    Kerry Goodhue
    Cake eyeliner

    It’s great. I am glad I finally found it. Thanks.

    Shelley Schoenherr
    Not of quality or worth an order

    Quality of the cake eyeliner is quite low. The eyeliner comes off almost upon first touch. It can't be blended or thinned out to make the gray shadowy tone because it bubbles and flakes. In adequate coverage. Very very disappointing. I really wanted this to be a substitute to the Clinique waterproof eyeliner that I have used until they discontinued it. This was a waste of good money to have ordered this product but I live and learn


    I really like the fact that the Ben Nye cake eyeliner is water based instead of a gel. I have tried every pen and gel eyeliner on the market and not one works at all! Years ago, I used Maybelline, Physicians Formula and Fran Wilson cake eyeliner but they took their water based off the market. Laura Mercier cake eyeliner I'm allergic to. The last few years I have been using Maybelline black eye shadow as eyeliner - messy. It's taking me a while to adjust to the Ben Nye brand because it goes on so thinly, I found I have to use a minute amount of water and go over the line many times. It doesn't make nice full black line. It looks like it's mixed with oil when I brush it on and I have to keep going over it to fill in the spaces. I also think I am getting an allergic reaction to it because my vision starts to blur.